On this episode we’re missing Brian, who had a last-minute before-Christmas dinner thing. So We’re joined by Brandon Isleib, better known as the Seedborn Muse over on the Muse Vessel! Of course, you’ll be able to find him over on Gathering Magic on Tuesdays from now on, so maybe you should check that out too. But since we had a guest host, we decided to make a potpourri episode of random smaller topics that have come up recently.
First off there’s a quick discussion of the two cards Banned from Modern. Then we took a quick look at Avacyn Restored. We let Brandon cut loose on a topic we recently we recently talked about, keeping casual Magic casual. Then there was a discussion of creatures with Defender in multiplayer Magic. We finished up with a nice long discussion about the various mechanics in Future Sight and which of them were our favorites. That one was a good one.
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
Back in in the fall of 2004, which was roughly between the end of Mirrodin block and the beginning of Kamigawa block, Brian wanted to try his hand at set design. So he created a set of 150 cards. Other than a bit of templating work and updating to include new terminology and keywords, these cards exist exactly as Brian originally created them. It’s an interesting look back at the way sets were designed back then, as well as the way Brian took the old design philosophies in his own direction. Chewie and Mike added some commentary just for good measure. You can also read the White, Blue, and Black cards. We hope you enjoy this trip back as much as we do!
Next, we’ve got red’s cards. Red’s themes here are pretty much what you would expect- burn and more burn. A few uncommon and rare cards push toward red being more mono-centric than the other colors, rewarding having lots of Mountains in particular. The Firespouter cycle was an attempt at making an interesting firebreathing variant, where the common and uncommon cards have a drawback and the rare has an upside. Flaming Rat was a combination of Spark Elemental and Viashino Sandstalker, intended to be a good one-drop common that would be quality even if drawn later, especially with creature pump. Kitchen Fire is now infamous on the show just for the noise you have to make when you play it (WOOO!), but has some implication for forcing the opponent to make hard choices when played during their upkeep. Magma Ritual was an attempt at making a “fixed” Dark Ritual in the “right” color- it’s one of those cards that I keep expecting to see printed in real Magic, but not yet.
Way back in in the fall of 2004, which would be roughly between the end of the first Mirrodin block and the beginning of Kamigawa block, Brian decided he wanted to try his hand at set design. So he created a set of 150 cards. Other than a bit of templating work and updating to include new terminology and keywords, these cards exist exactly as Brian originally created them. It’s an interesting look back at the way sets were designed back then, as well as the way Brian took the old design philosophies in his own direction. Chewie and Mike added some commentary just for good measure too. You can see the White and Blue cards too. We hope you enjoy this trip back as much as we do!
On to black. There’s a number of Rat cards here, largely because Kamigawa hadn’t been even spoiled yet and I had always liked cards like Plague Rats and Lab Rats. Black has been through many signature small signature creature types like zombies (and more recently vampires), and I thought that the rats should have a shot. A lot of black’s creatures here are into sacrifice, and cards like Death Contract and Body Exchange play off of this theme as well. Consumer of Rot harkens back to drawbacks like Desecration Elemental, and may not belong at uncommon, but some of my cards were clearly designed with concept first and rarity consideration second (if at all). One Hundred Blind Eyes is probably the card I would be most interested in seeing the art for in black, if not the whole set. Slave to the Moon was my attempt at making a “good” werewolf ages before Innistrad.
Hey look, Bill’s back! And since he’s here, we begin this episode by talking all about the SCG Invitational we went to last week. We’ve got all kindsa stories and people and things. There are links to the two playmats we talked about a little further down. And you know you wanna see
Then we have a Magic Mad Lib from Myke Okuhara, which is seriously drop-dead hilarious. No really. I might die. Then we did a real Mad Lib that Brian wrote, because it was there to do. Just don’t get used to this two-Mad-Libs-per-episode thing going on here, okay?
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
Way back in in the fall of 2004, which would be roughly between the end of the first Mirrodin block and the beginning of Kamigawa block and WELL before the formation of The Mana Pool (that was 2007), Brian decided he wanted to try his hand at set design. So that’s just what he did, creating a set of 150 cards. Other than a bit of templating work and updating to include new terminology and keywords, these cards exist exactly as Brian originally created them. It’s an interesting look back at the way sets were designed back then, as well as the way Brian took the old design philosophies in his own direction. Be sure to go check out the White cards too. We hope you enjoy this trip back as much as we do!
Today we’ve got blue. Whereas white had a very strong central theme in high toughness and defense, the cards in blue are not nearly as in sync. There’s a few bounce spells, some card draw, some flying creatures, and some counterspells. The Aether cycle of cards are based around bounce. Otherwise, you’ve got to look to individual cards to get a sense of what was going on. Stubborn Voidmage is pretty silly, but gets worse if combined with things like white’s Armor Rack. Logical Persuasion can be sacrificed at instant speed, which can create some interesting interactions. Baby Whale became a card (Grayscaled Gharial) in Ravnica, but Forced Denial had to wait another year before becoming Cancel in Time Spiral! As always, please leave your thoughts and comments below. Enjoy!